357 vs 10mm bear.

The .357 Sig is good for lightweight bullets, but the 10mm in the original Norma loading (200gr. jhp @ 1200fps) is an excellent self defense/hunting load for everything up to brown bears. Some folks carry it as a backup for grizzlies, but I'm not convinced that it's completely adequate. In a strong enough firearm, a load could be developed to ...Bear are tough critters to stop and kill. The best pistol for bear is a 12-ga. with a 20-in barrel. That being said, I have killed two bears with pistols; one black and one grizzly. Both ended up just a few feet from me. My choice for carrying as I fish is a 10mm Glock 20 with extremely hard cast (24 Brinell) projectiles that weigh 209 gr.10mm vs .357 Handguns: General Handgun Forum 10mm vs .357 - Page 4 - The Firing Line Forums The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: General Handgun ForumNov 20, 2022 · 10mm 200 gr XTP, 7.1 grains CFE Pistol at 1060 fps. 44 mag 300 gr XTP, 17.5 grains H110 at 1093 fps. The 10mm is a true .400” caliber whereas the 44 actually measures .429” diameter. Interestingly enough, there was little velocity difference between the loads even with just over 10 more grains of powder in the 44 mag.

Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...The 10mm’s recoil is akin to a 357 Magnum with a good deal of flash, noise, recoil, and muzzle associated with true 10mm loads. The argument that you can download 10mm doesn’t hold water. If that’s the case, then we are arguing 40 S&W versus 45 ACP, not 10mm versus 45 ACP. 10mm is a powerful round that requires the shooter to train …Check out PDN! https://go.personaldefensenetwork.com/mac/Join Patreon and support MAC! http://www.patreon.com/militaryarms Follow and support us on Utreon!:...

I answered .357 SIG, but the truth is it depends. If I was in brown bear country I'd want a 10mm, but if I had to use .357 SIG or .40 S&W it would be a tossup. .357 SIG is generally going to have more energy, but a heavier .40 caliber bullet would be at least slightly more effective at penetrating the skull (especially with cast bullets).Aug 10, 2018 ... In this sequel to "Bears versus Guns", James revisits his earlier decision to carry a .44 magnum as a grizzly bear defense sidearm in Alaska ...

Having read that the US Fish and Game guys carried .357 Mag in bear country, but this was in the 1970s, and I have no ides how true that was or is now, I figured 10mm S&W with hardball would do the job even better, but the hunters I …The .45 ACP is perfectly capable of taking down a coyote or even a deer at close distances, but the .357 is a far more effective hunting cartridge, especially in a rifle. Both can be used on small and medium game, but the .357 is more effective on deer-sized animals and can step up to larger animals like bears. Winner: .357 Magnum.The 10mm will get you about 12.5-16" of penetration again depending on the company you buy, and while great it penetrates more factor in recoil vs gun, vs the abuse the gun takes etc. Matter of choice but the reality is the .357-10mm only means inches of penetration not the ability to stop someone which is solely in shot placement.Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...

Osaa baseball playoffs

10+1 of 10mm 1911 or 15+1 in a Glock 20 vs 6 or 7 in a wheelgun. Shot placement will be key. I went with the 10mm for a recent trip to Idaho and Colorado and went with handloaded Lehigh Extreme Penetrators in the primary mag with the secondary mag containing Federal 180 JSP.

Self-Defense vs. Hunting. It's worth noting that the test standards outlined above were developed with human targets in mind. For animals, the 150% expansion and the 12-18" penetration guidelines do not necessarily apply. 10mm has recently gained some popularity as a hunting cartridge for small to medium game, and it also comes up often in discussions about "wilderness defense" against ...The .40 S&W is sparked by a small pistol primer, while the 10mm uses a large pistol primer. The larger and faster 10mm will give 624 foot-pounds of muzzle energy when sending a 180-grain bullet at ...When it comes to bear protection, a .45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) is generally considered inadequate. Bears are large and powerful animals, and a larger caliber like a .44 Magnum or a shotgun loaded with slugs is recommended for effective defense. Contents [ show]By Nahid July 8, 2023. The 10mm xtreme penetrator versus bear is a comparison of two powerful projectiles used for hunting. When it comes to stopping power and penetration, the 10mm xtreme penetrator stands out. This bullet is known for its superior performance, with its unique design allowing for deep penetration and devastating wound channels.The 357 mag made for an excellent self-defense round for many years, and countless people still carry it for self-defense today. Making the 10mm vs 357 magnum argument interesting because many people thought the 10mm would make the 357 mag obsolete.. The 44 mag was designed for hunting and self-defense purposes for big game, not necessarily human threats.Now if I were concerned more about bear or hogs in the country-side, that's where I'd consider 10mm. However at a 10 round limit I'd actually consider an 8-round .357 magnum wheel gun too. 10mm has seen a decent resurgence with platforms and loads, but .357 still is better for availability.The .357 has better SD and better penetration and more energy. 10mm will cover most anything a .357 can do so they are pretty much interchangeable in the woods. On the street added firepower of 10mm would be an advantage. So go with your 10mm. For big dangerous stuff you would want .44, .45 .454, .460, .475, .500.

The .44 Special is well-suited to long-range target shooting due to its low recoil and excellent accuracy, while the .357 Magnum is excellent for short- to mid-range targets. The .44 Special and .357 Magnum are both excellent choices for self-defense. The .44 Special is a great choice for those who want a powerful handgun without the punishing ...lol, reddit has a pretty intense feedback loop of catridge hate for 357 sig. 10mm people are tolerated because they are not a serious threat. Its a psychological thing; people payfor a 9mm pistol then become emotionally attached. As for .357 sig vs .40 S&W, I think it is a fine step up from 40, especially in full sized handguns.The 45 ACP Glock 30 is much more comfortable and easy to shoot. The 45 ACP has that slow-rolling recoil, whereas the 10mm has that snap and fury. The 45 ACP allows for faster follow-up shots and at average self-defense ranges, follow up shots are important. The 45 ACP tends to be less flashy in shorter barrels as well.This Motivated video pits the outstanding .357 Sig against the 10MM monster. The scientifically calibrated motivated ballistics medium consists of two cinder...The 10mm Glock can work for bear defense. I would load some Buffalo Bore hard cast in it and go forth. My personal choice would be a S&W Mountain gun in 44 mag loaded with 240 hard cast SWC at about 1400 FPS. By the time you load 15 rounds of 10mm and an extra magazine or 2, you are at the same weight as the Smith 44.Real world results have shown it to be quite effective. Additionally, the video I posted in the OP shows very little difference in effectiveness between the 10mm and 9mm. If you conclude that the 9mm is "too weak" for bear defense, then by definition, so is the 10mm.

Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...The .357 Sig is good for lightweight bullets, but the 10mm in the original Norma loading (200gr. jhp @ 1200fps) is an excellent self defense/hunting load for everything up to brown bears. Some folks carry it as a backup for grizzlies, but I'm not convinced that it's completely adequate. In a strong enough firearm, a load could be developed to ...

Many Game Commission officers in bear country use the 357 Sig or 10mm for a reason. I love the 10mm in its full power form but it is a bigger and heavier firearm platform. Anything I would shoot with the 10mm, I would shoot with a hot 357 Sig round as bullet placement is still a major part of the equation when ending a 4 legged threat.As of writing this article, the lowest per-round cost for the 9mm was $0.14, while the lowest per-round for the .357 Magnum was $0.27. (Both were FMJ rounds from Tula Ammo.) However, the highest-cost for the 9mm Luger was $1.95, while the highest per-round price for .357 Magnum was $1.90. But in this case we are looking at two different ...Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Long, drawn out bear markets may be rather for the indexes, but for individual stocks? Not so....M Someone asked on Monday if long, drawn out bear markets are now going to be a thi...One factor will be your location and preferences. For example someone that lives in Alaska will probably go with a .44 Magnum, but someone in Michigan would use a Ruger GP100 .357. Also, this caliber is better for longer range than a .45ACP. .45 ACP users are mostly EDC personal defense carriers and those that love the big bores.Sep 26, 2023. #20. Only a handful of companies actually load 10mm to it's proper powerhouse levels. Underwood being the flagship ammo. Why carry a 6 shot .357 when you can have a Glock 20 with 15rds of 10mm semi-auto. 20 round mag plus are also available. Now with the Gen 5 mos you cent even mount the red dot optic of your choice.Since the 44 Magnum always beats out the 357 Magnum in terms of stopping power, it comes as no surprise that it trounces the newer 10mm as well. ... the 44 Mag's definitive stopping power will prove more effective for boar, deer, and even bear. A semi-auto 10mm handgun naturally offers increased shot capacity, a faster rate of fire, and an ...The 10mm Auto is no slouch either. Where the .357 Sig shines with lighter bullets at ridiculous velocities, the 10mm gains its edge in being able to push heavier pills. The 10mm can push bullets from 165 grains to over 200. The 10mm can push a 200-grain FMJ or a 200-grain JHP from the muzzle at 1,250 feet per second.Originally Posted by OSOKSo, Kevin, why are you getting in so many fights with black bears? Are you out there calling them names or something? Lotsa youth, not much brains. I have mellowed in my later years and I now no longer push any issue with a bear unless he's on my property. Have...

Lane keeping assist problem acura

.357 vs 44 mag vs 10mm Bear gun Thread starter Yankee1956; ... 10mm, .357M, and .44M. I wouldn't know, personally. I'm just reporting what I've heard. I suppose semi-autos need to be well-tested with wide flat nose ammo. Revolvers will be good-to-go regardless of bullet shape, obviously. ...

Just no. Shooting a bear with a .40 or a 10mm or a .223 is my option near the bottom of the list. Running is a better one. Tin Foil Free Zone. Eagle Scout. ... which seems to be the generally accepted minimum by those who've never shot a black bear. A .357 mag is oft-times considered "ok" for such things, and a well loaded .40 S&W is …In fact, many people believe that the 45 colt is actually a better choice for protection against grizzly attacks than the 357 magnum. This is because the 45 colt produces less recoil and muzzle blast, making it easier to shoot accurately in close quarters situations. Additionally, the larger diameter of the bullet means that it will penetrate ...Never owned a 10mm but have carried the .357 in either a Coonan Model B or 10" TC Contender afield. ... Carried the Marlin 1894 in .41 Mag (270 gr WFN at 1600 fps) last year for specifically black bear but they didn't bother to read the text also . I did harvest a deer last year with my M16A4 clone in 5.56mm before going after bear. CD . Last ...The Glock 10mm with its capacity puts more foot pounds of energy on target than any reasonable handgun out there. That is a good way to put it.....potential energy on target vs time to shoot. This is why I choose a semi auto. .357 @ 700ftlbs x 6rds = 4200. 10mm @ 650ft lbs x 12rds = 7800.The minimum handgun caliber for bear defense is the 10mm AUTO. It fires a .40 in. bullet, between 180 and 220 grains. The heavier bullets are on par with a 45 but are faster and more powerful. ... The .357 Magnum fires a bulet very close to the 9mm but way faster. You shoud use the heaviest bullet you can get, preferebly 180 grain going around ...10mm vs .357 mag Underwood Xtreme Penetrators for Bear Protection? Alaskan Ballistics. 38.8K subscribers. Subscribed. 3.5K. 127K views 2 years ago. 10mm …Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a 10mm Auto round averages out to 550 ft-lb, while a .454 Casull round averages out to about 1700 ft-lb. One way to think about this is as such: a foot-pound is a unit of energy equal to the amount of energy required to raise a weight of one pound a distance of one foot. So a 10mm Auto round exits the barrel ...In a bear attack you'll be lucky to get off more than a couple shots. Just a cursory glance of the foot pounds energy has it around 700 for the 10mm, compared to around 1000+ for 44 magnum, which is what most recommend using at a minimum against Grizzlies. It's not the energy that matters.Gummy bears are probably one of you child's favorite snacks; they are tasty and irresistibly cute. But when your child drops a gummy bear in your car, it often goes unnoticed until...The key being “hit,” misses don’t count and a non-vital hit won’t stop the charge no matter what you’re shooting. The primary appeal of the 10mm is that it gives adequate bullet weight and velocity- but with double or triple the number of shots vs a revolver. In my one and only bear encounter, I fired 8 rounds of 10mm in about 2 seconds.The .357 mag is about the minimum in power for protection against large predators or against large game. That doesn't mean that It's ineffective, just that there …

The .44 Special is well-suited to long-range target shooting due to its low recoil and excellent accuracy, while the .357 Magnum is excellent for short- to mid-range targets. The .44 Special and .357 Magnum are both excellent choices for self-defense. The .44 Special is a great choice for those who want a powerful handgun without the punishing ...Get a hollow point round. Black bears are not overly tough like their bigger and meaner cousins. People who say otherwise have not personally had to deal with them. Although, if you have a 10mm pistol or a revolver larger than the .357 available to you, just take that instead of buying something new. 5.I have a sig P229 in .40 S&W. I can get a drop in .357 Sig barrel replacement for around $200.00. If you have the 40 already, and have a SPARE $200 for the .357 sig, use $175-$180 and a good shape used 12 guage shotgun that can take the 3" slugs.. use the spare money for ammo and a bear spray can.. then bring the 40 as back up loaded hot.Instagram:https://instagram. lost lands 6 puzzle solutions According to the California Department of Fish & Game, the average weight of a black bear is around 300 pounds. The Maine Dept. of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife identifies the mean starting weight (for males) as being 250 pounds Whereas the former puts 500 pounds at the upper end of the weight spectrum, the latter notes 600 pounds In reality ...The .45 ACP cannot be relied on to bring down medium sized game animals like deer where as the .357 Magnum (with the right bullets and load) is a renowned deerslayer. The .357 can also take small ... fox 13+ seattle Depending on which website you go to there seems to be conflicting opinion regarding ballistics. Thinking in terms of trail protection, is it fair to say they are pretty damned close, if you want a semi-auto go with a 10mm, if you want a revolver take the .357, but basically other than ...Why carry a 6 shot .357 when you can have a Glock 20 with 15rds of 10mm semi-auto. 20 round mag plus are also available. Now with the Gen 5 mos you cent even mount the red dot optic of your choice. IMHO I rather have 15-20 round mag dump on a charging bear than a flimsy 5-6 shot revolver. usaa platinum visa card 2. Smith & Wesson 610. Chambered in 10mm, the Smith and Wesson model 610 is a good choice for bear defense. Not only is this handgun capable of firing a 10mm round, but is also adaptable to the 40 caliber cartridge. Additionally, this handgun comes in both 4 inch and 6.5 inch barrel configurations. outback steakhouse parsippany Modern firearms doctrine has very much moved on to "more bullets = more better" instead of "bigger bullets = more better" so the .357 SIG actually exceeds the original in this regard. The rounds are also smaller and lighter than the .357 Magnum's, which makes carrying extras a lot less of a pain.NFL games today include Bears vs Vikings and Eagles vs Redskins, but no Sunday Night Football. Here's how to watch NFL games free online. By clicking "TRY IT", I agree to receive n... calfresh income limits 2023 riverside county The minimum recommended caliber for grizzly bear defense is typically .357 Magnum, with larger calibers being preferred for maximum effectiveness. 12. Is a 10mm more powerful than a .357 Magnum? In general, a 10mm is more powerful than a .357 Magnum, making it a popular choice for bear defense. 13. Can a .38 Special be used for brown bear defense? border collie small mix My pasture/land/hiking carry. G20. Will kill damn near anything if I could hit my target. I need more practice with it though.View attachment 721857 Loaded w/full house 220gr Underwood Flat Nose Hard Cast Boolits 10mm Auto 220gr. Flat Nose Black Cherry Coated Hard Cast Hunting Ammo View attachment 721858 I have at least 20 or 30 miles hiking relatively rugged terrain with this rig and it holds ...Ultimately, the quick answer is that 10mm Auto has higher muzzle velocity and, therefore, more recoil. On average, a 230-grain 45 ACP round has 7.5 ft-lbs (foot-pounds) of felt recoil, while a 180-grain 10mm load has 11.4 ft-lbs. That means the 10mm has over 50% more recoil than the 45 ACP, which is pretty substantial for many shooters. math problem solving iep goals high school And I hang out smack in the middle of the greatest concentration of grizzlies in the lower 48. I carry the 357 once in a while but it is a lot of extra weight. Not fond it. Black bears in NH? I wouldn't worry about it. But if you want bear protection, shoot what you can shoot accurately. Tough to be the accuracy of bear spray, kind of like a ...Like & Subscribe😁 Thank you for watching!! Contact: [email protected] for any questions or ammo donations for testing. Thanks again!!Ruger Security S...Jitterbug. Except shooting shot shells 10mm will do anything a .357 will do and visa versa, after handloading and shooting both the past 40 years I find them to be just about ballistic twins. I find the 10mm an easier carry, higher mag capacity, less recoil and blast and overall a more preferable caliber and platform especially in 1911. fssp atlanta The practical end uses of the .357 are many and varied, such as hunting, self-defense (plenty of stopping power), home defense and target shooting. It’s also very forgiving to make handloads for. Guns as small as the S&W J-Frame are readily available and carry easily. The .44 Magnum, on the other hand, struggles greatly in small guns. enroute delivery meaning The expense is considerably greater than .40 (the default LE cartridge until recently) and the efficacy is debatable. Bullet science shows that faster and smaller has a better damage:recoil ratio, take for example 10MM vs .45. .357 sig does more damage than 9, 40, and 45.But they have been proven to work well over time. I would go with the hard case even if the cost was the same but the Extreme Penetrator is more expensive at $31/box of 20 vs. $19 for the hard cast ammo, both from Underwood. Not enough to worry about if you are only buying one box. halifax county nc mugshots Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Add a Comment. Wraccores • 1 hr. ago. .357 Sig has .40S&W pressure. 10mm has higher pressure than .40S&W. Ergo: 10mm has higher pressure than .357 Sig, and will have better M.E. than .357 Sig. 11. Reply. Jeremy_Dewitte1 • 1 hr. ago. Not really a good comparison, 10mm is longer and thus these two use different platforms. zillow napa county ca As of 2014, a Smith & Wesson .357 Magnum ranges in price from $1,079 to $1,559, depending on the model of the revolver. The most expensive magnum is the Model 627 V-Comp, and the c...The significance of the 10mm Auto caliber in law enforcement circles can mostly be attributed to a tragic event that took place on April 11, 1986. On that day, there was a devastating shootout between FBI agents in Miami and two bank robbers who were wanted. Unfortunately, this incident resulted in the loss of two agents.